He Used State Minimum Wage Laws to Justify a $0 Tip. Why the ‘California Excuse’ is the Ultimate Red Flag.

For as long as most of us can remember, the rules of dining out have been simple: you enjoy a lovely meal, and you leave a gratuity for the person who served you. It is a gesture of appreciation, a thank you for a job well done. This small act of courtesy is a cornerstone of American dining etiquette.

However, it seems the lines are getting blurry for some. One gentleman recently took to the internet to ask a question that struck a nerve with many, wondering if it was time to stop tipping altogether.

The Incident

The story begins with a man from California who was wrestling with a question of principle. He explained that in his state, servers are required to be paid at least the standard minimum wage, unlike in many other places where a lower “tipped minimum wage” is the norm. Because of this, he felt the main justification for tipping was no longer valid.

“It seems to me that the common argument for tipping in the US, that waiters and waitresses are paid far below the minimum wage because of the expectation of tips, is at some level moot,” he wrote. He couldn’t understand why servers should receive extra money when so many others in difficult, minimum-wage jobs do not.

He posed the question, “There are lots of other jobs with people working hard to only get paid minimum wage and I’m not expected to tip them… so why arbitrarily favor waiters and waitresses?”

To be clear, he wasn’t suggesting he would never tip. He clarified that he “would still tip for exceptional service,” but not as a default expectation. He admitted he was hesitant to actually put his theory into practice, fearing he would receive poor service at his favorite restaurants. Still, the very idea of withholding a standard tip based on a personal principle felt, to many, like a serious breach of social custom.

The Internet Reacts

As you can imagine, the internet had plenty to say. People’s reactions fell into a few distinct camps, each with a strong opinion on the matter.

First, there was the “Absolutely Not” crowd, who were appalled by the man’s logic. Many of them were former servers who understood the physical and emotional toll of the job. One person put it bluntly: “You would be the a..hole for refusing to tip based on a principle as opposed to tipping or not tipping based on the quality of the service you were given.”

Another former waitress passionately defended her profession. “Serving is a very very hard job, if I was getting paid minimum wage I would have quit and done something much easier,” she argued. “You know before going to a restaurant that the deal is you pay 20 percent for the service you receive… Don’t make someone work for you for free.”

Then there was the “Devil’s Advocate” camp. These folks understood where the man was coming from, even if they didn’t fully agree. They saw his point about the inconsistency of tipping culture. “I can agree with this,” one commenter wrote. “What makes waiters and waitresses deserve tips, if they’re now getting minimum wage like every other job, who do not get tips at all? At that point, tips should be… given if deserved, not required.”

Finally, there were the “Educators,” who tried to explain the nuances of the system. One person pointed out that even if California law is different, the national culture of tipping is built around a system where tips are essential. They explained that in many states, servers receive a much lower hourly wage from their employer with the expectation that tips will make up the difference.

“While I also do not agree with tipping culture how it is, you’d be the a..hole for taking away part of their livelihood,” they concluded. The conversation even branched into what the standard tip should be, with some insisting 20% is the rule while others felt 15% was still perfectly acceptable.

The Etiquette Verdict

While the debate around tipping culture is certainly a valid one, changing the system should not come at the expense of the individual server standing at your table. When you decide to sit down for a meal at a full-service restaurant in this country, you are agreeing to participate in a long-standing social contract. Part of that contract involves tipping for the service you receive.

Withholding a tip based on a personal principle punishes the worker, not the system. It is simply unfair to make your server the target of your protest. Good manners dictate that we treat service workers with respect, and in our culture, that respect is often shown through a fair and appropriate gratuity.

Your Thoughts

Is tipping an outdated system that needs to go, or is it a necessary part of showing appreciation for service?

Ready for the next level of insight? Discover more in my latest article here.