Girlfriend Begged to Go to a Fancy New Opening, Then Planned to Order from the Kid’s Menu. I Canceled the Date.

There are certain truths we hold dear when it comes to dining etiquette. One of the great joys of going out for a meal is the shared experience—trying new flavors, appreciating a chef’s craft, and enjoying good company in a lovely setting. As we get older, we expect our tastes, and those of our partners, to mature beyond the children’s menu.

However, one man recently shared a story online that shows what happens when your dinner date has the palate of a ten-year-old, and he’s the one footing the bill.

The Incident

A gentleman took to the internet to share a dilemma he was having with his girlfriend. While he describes himself as an adventurous eater who has lived all over the world, his girlfriend is, to put it mildly, an incredibly picky eater. Her list of forbidden foods is long and includes things most of us consider staples: onions, garlic, fish, eggs, and even potatoes unless they are french fries.

This difference in taste becomes a major issue when they go out to nice restaurants. No matter the cuisine, whether it’s an “authentic Nepalese restaurant” or a place with a dress code, she defaults to the same order: chicken tenders and fries. The man admits he finds this embarrassing, but the real problem is financial. He is the one who typically pays for their dates.

As he put it, “It especially bothers me that since I typically pay, I end up paying 15 bucks for chicken tenders that I could get from the freezer section at Walmart for 5 bucks.”

The situation came to a head when a new, pricey dinner spot opened up, and his girlfriend was “dying to go.” When she confirmed she’d just order her usual, he finally snapped. “I asked her what’s the point of going then if I can toss some tenders in the air fryer for her and not spend a ridiculous amount of money on it,” he wrote. His girlfriend was hurt, accusing him of thinking he was “better than her,” leaving him wondering if he was in the wrong.

The Internet Reacts

The online community had plenty to say, with thousands of people weighing in on this culinary conflict. Most readers fell into one of three camps.

First, there was the “Absolutely Not” crowd, who were completely on the boyfriend’s side. They felt the girlfriend’s behavior was not just childish, but inconsiderate. One commenter didn’t mince words, writing, “I hate people like this. Grown… adults who eat like a kid… Develop a palate. I would never date someone like that.”

Another user got straight to the point of the matter: “What’s the point of going to a restaurant that is charging high prices for the food experience if you aren’t going to actually take part in that experience.” One particularly blunt reader added, “Go to a fast food joint if you want to eat that. At least there she can get a toy to keep her company.”

Then came the “Devil’s Advocate” camp, which tried to understand the girlfriend’s perspective. Perhaps the food wasn’t the point for her. “I am trying to put myself in her headspace and maybe she wants to have a reason to get dressed up,” one person suggested.

Another agreed, noting there’s “nothing wrong with wanting to go out on a date night with your partner, picky eater or not.” Some wondered if she had sensory issues or food aversions, which would make her picky eating less of a choice and more of a challenge she has to live with.

Finally, there was the “Practical Solution” group. These commenters skipped the drama and offered simple, fair-minded advice. The most popular suggestion by far was for the girlfriend to pay for her own meal. As one person wrote, “why can’t she pay this time?

If she wants to go to the restaurant then she can pay for the meal and order whatever she wants.” Another user offered a witty compromise: “Of course, if that’s true, the solution here is to have a dressy candlelit chicken tender dinner at home lmao.”

The Etiquette Verdict

While everyone is entitled to their own food preferences, this situation goes beyond simple likes and dislikes. The issue here is one of respect and financial fairness. Going to a fine dining restaurant is about more than just eating; it’s about appreciating the ambiance, the artistry of the chef, and the shared experience.

To demand that your partner take you to an expensive establishment, on his dime, only to refuse to participate in the very thing that makes it special, is simply bad manners. It shows a lack of appreciation for both his money and the experience he is trying to share with you.

What Do You Think?

Now we want to hear from you. Is the boyfriend being a food snob who should just let his girlfriend eat what she wants, or is she taking advantage of his generosity by demanding pricey dates for freezer-aisle food?

Ready for the next level of insight? Discover more in my latest article here.